President
ICAI
Subject: Continuous Harassment By Noida Police to a CA due to certification & thretening to put him in jail and to recover the money of fraud from CA
Dear Sir,
Our professional brother from noida is being harassed by Noida police for certification.Kindly direct noida branch to meet DSP, SP to resolve the issue. Kindly provide all support to manoj jee. Kindly look into matter urgently. His letter is as follows:
DEAR ALL,
I am a practicing Chartered Accountant running my own CA firm in Noida since 2005. Before three months a person namely Mr. Vikrant Bajaj came to my office with his documents and requested for a CA certification for opening bank account with Axis Bank.I issued a certificate to the bank, in which I verified the name and address of the person on the basis of the following documents:-
1) PAN Card (issued by Income Tax Department),
2) ST-2, Service tax registration certificate (issued by Central Board of Excise and Custom); and
3) voter-id card (issued by Election Comission of India).It was clearly mentioned in the certificate that this certificate is issued on the basis of these documents only. It was nowhere mentioned that I take his guarantee or responsibility or I know him.
On 28th March, a police inspector Mr. Pradeep Kumar enquired me about Mr. Vikrant Bajaj. He told me that Mr. Vikrant Bajaj has committed some crime and is missing. I informed the inspector that He comes to me with original documents to issue a certificate to open a Bank Account with Axis Bank. I
verified documents. PAN and ST-2 were active documents and registered with respective government authorities. I issued certificate after taking care of due diligence. I also told him that I don't know him personally.But still the police inspector made pressure upon me and force me to make available Mr. Vikram Bajaj before him. He is threatening me that If you don't produce Mr. Vikram Bajaj before him then they will held responsible to me for each and every thing they do and put me in jail and will recover
the money of fraud from me. This behavior of Mr. Pradreep Kumar is quite strange. He is talking senselessly. Whatever I have done is a part of my professional duties only. I have issued certificate
with due diligence. I clearly mentioned in the certificate also that this certificate is issued only on the basis of documents produced before us. Mr. Pradeep Kumar is calling me from his mobile no. 9818318137 again and again and harassing me baselessly. This conduct of a police inspector is
very painful. I don't understand whether Police is to help public or to harass public. If I am guilty to issue a certificate after verification of documents issued by government authorities then all government authorities who issued the documents will also held quilty. I just issued a certificate but government authorities do registrations. If Police will behave like this and held responsible to professionals only due to certification done by them after taking care of due diligence, then no Chartered Accountant, Company Secretaries, Advocates, Ghazatted Officer will certify any documents of any person. Why government give us an authority to certify the documents of people? "This is a time to come together and tell everyone that we professionals are doing our jobs with due diligence and no one can raise any finger against professionals unnecessary."
CA Manoj Garg(FCA, DISA)*
Manoj Ratan & AssociatesChartered Accountants*Office :- C-302, First Floor,
Sec-10, Noida,U.P.-201301
Phone - +91 0120 4219674
Mobile - +91 9899416237
<http://www.manojratanassociates.com/>
1) To remain safe from our side, It would be best if we stop certifying
documents of any unknown person other than our regular clients. It is
really shameful to know that, such harassment happening to reputed
professionals like CA's. Hope Noida Centre of ICAI will take up the
matter seriously and help Manoj ji.
CA Sagar Bhandari
Nepal
2) MAJAZ AHMAD BHAT camajaz@gmail.com
This is an eye wash for our Babus at the helm of affairs and they should avoid making their own network instead should do for the whole CA fraternity.
3) Why do we certify these funny things and which are not financial statements.
if banks ask or use CAs just for fun like this cert. where orginals are with the person and bank it self can realy and why do they ask from a CA. other examples banks ask to certify projections where are just against the ethics
GYAN
4) Institute should take action against this.
CA. Amit Goyal
5) This is the TIME when we all should stand united. This matter should not have be referred to the police .
Jagdish Pahuja jkpahuja12@gmail.com
6) DEAR ALL,
IT IS REALLY PAIN FULL FOR THE TREATMENT METED OUT TO CA'S ALL AROUND. WHAT WAS HE CERTIFYING. ITS ONLY THE PERSONS IDENTITY AND ADDRESS. DID IT SIGNIFY THAT HE IS CERTIFYING THAT HE WILL NOT CHEAT OR DO ANY UNLAWFUL THING. AND IF HE COMMITS ANY UNLAWFUL THING THAN CA WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SAME.BUT IF THE SAME IS CERTIFIED BY THE LAWYERS THAN NO BODY WILL EVEN COME TO QUESTION THEM. ITS A PITY OF OUR LIFE THAT WE ARE ALWAYS TREATED BEHIND ADVOCATES IN ALL WALKS OF LIFE.
CA. SUNIL KUMAR JAIN
7) Generallly these kind of certificate are issued to banks that the person is known personally. If a person issues a certificate just based on pan card or voting car does not mean tha he may not know him personally. In my opinion such certificate should not be issued unless one knows personally. We should take legal opinion before making it a big issue.
O p agarwal
8) Dear Professional friends
we should save our profession.we should make strong community for From this incident I would like to impress all my fellow colleagues to not issue any certificate to walk in client. Walk in client is welcome for all professional assignments but we should be careful if unknown person asks for only a certificate from us
FCA MANISH GUPTA
MANISH SHIV GUPTA AND ASSOCIATES
9) Dear CA 'S
This is one of the Serious Harassment by the Police Required to be deeply Protest by CA Fraternity of all India irrespective of States.
Further Serious Steps to be taken by CA general elected body so that stern action including suspension from service would be acted against the Police officers .
CA RAMESH K KEJRIWAL
Senior Partner
Thanks & Regards
KEJRIWAL & ASSOCIATES
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS
13&14,Apex Market Complex
Kalpana Square,Cuttack Road
BHUBANESWAR -751006,Odisha
TEL/FAX-2310033,M-9437043043
Email :Kejriwalfca@yahoo.com
Web: www.Kejriwalfca.com
10) Praveen kpraveenca@gmail.com
Its really senseless act the police men.
11) Rishu Gupta rishugupta_cj@yahoo.co.in
This is strange and shameful. This should be stopped.
12) Rohit Agnihotri carohitagnihotri@gmail.com
We are with you
13) Dear Nitesh Ji
Current set up of police system in our country has made it gundaraj in the hands of police to harass anybody whosoever they want to or pressurized to. We should unite together and represent as one force to the higher authorities of Mr Pradeep. This police community is afraid of media because of their reach. We should also set up an example so that police think twice before harassing any CA unnecessarily. This way we will be able to survive together in this cruel set up.
Please let me know about any help from side.
With regards
CA. Akhil Prashar
14) Dear professional colleague
The whole episode is quite unfortunate and we all are professionals and doing the due diligence to the best of our knowledge and belief and on the basis of information produced to us for our verification. The harassment by police is not desirable and Central council members and especially those representing CA MANOJ GARG region should immediately come forward and initiate action. We all are with him.
CA TARUN KANSAL
FCA,BCOM (Hons), LLB, DIRM, DISA
SVP & ASSOCIATES
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS
1209, NEW DELHI HOUSE,
27, BARAKHAMBA ROAD,
CONNAUGHT PLACE,
NEW DELHI-110001
15) This is very serious matter….This matter should be brought immediately in the notice of ICAI president & Noida officials. And they should speak to SP NOida on this immediately.
Nitishji I request you to speak personally with ICAI officials….
We are all with CA Manoj Garg…..
Thanks
Rohit Gupta
FCA, CS.
09811175141
16) To remain safe from our side, It would be best if we stop certifying documents of any unknown person other than our regular clients. It is
really shameful to know that, such harassment happening to reputed professionals like CA's. Hope Noida Centre of ICAI will take up the matter seriously and help Manoj ji.
CA Sagar Bhandari
Nepal
17) Dear All,
We should take action against this type of officials, because this thing can happen with any of us in future, I request all to join hands.
CA Prakhar Gupta, Rishikesh
18) Girish Vakharia vakhariagirish@gmail.com
In India brutality of cops is well known . If a CA feels helpless, what about an illiterate villager's plight. Unless the cops are punished adequately, cop atrocities will not end
19) DEAR ALL,
IT IS REALLY PAIN FULL FOR THE TREATMENT METED OUT TO CA'S ALL AROUND. WHAT WAS HE CERTIFYING. ITS ONLY THE PERSONS IDENTITY AND ADDRESS. DID IT SIGNIFY THAT HE IS CERTIFYING THAT HE WILL NOT CHEAT OR DO ANY UNLAWFUL THING. AND IF HE COMMITS ANY UNLAWFUL THING THAN CA WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SAME.BUT IF THE SAME IS CERTIFIED BY THE LAWYERS THAN NO BODY WILL EVEN COME TO QUESTION THEM. ITS A PITY OF OUR LIFE THAT WE ARE ALWAYS TREATED BEHIND ADVOCATES IN ALL WALKS OF LIFE.
CA. SUNIL KUMAR JAIN
20) HIMANSHU GUPTA <cahimanshuji@gmail.com>
I too support manoj ji. Complaint should be filed against police officer For harassment.
21) We all have to support our brother Mr. Manoj and help him to come out of such a worst situation.
Regards
Rajat jain
1) DEAR ALL,
IT IS REALLY PAIN FULL FOR THE TREATMENT METED OUT TO CA'S ALL AROUND. WHAT WAS HE CERTIFYING. ITS ONLY THE PERSONS IDENTITY AND ADDRESS. DID IT SIGNIFY THAT HE IS CERTIFYING THAT HE WILL NOT CHEAT OR DO ANY UNLAWFUL THING. AND IF HE COMMITS ANY UNLAWFUL THING THAN CA WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SAME.BUT IF THE SAME IS CERTIFIED BY THE LAWYERS THAN NO BODY WILL EVEN COME TO QUESTION THEM. ITS A PITY OF OUR LIFE THAT WE ARE ALWAYS TREATED BEHIND ADVOCATES IN ALL WALKS OF LIFE.
CA. SUNIL KUMAR JAIN
2) Generallly these kind of certificate are issued to banks that the person is known personally. If a person issues a certificate just based on pan card or voting car does not mean tha he may not know him personally. In my opinion such certificate should not be issued unless one knows personally. We should take legal opinion before making it a big issue.
O p agarwal
3) Dear Professional friends
we should save our profession.we should make strong community for From this incident I would like to impress all my fellow colleagues to not issue any certificate to walk in client. Walk in client is welcome for all professional assignments but we should be careful if unknown person asks for only a certificate from us
FCA MANISH GUPTA
MANISH SHIV GUPTA AND ASSOCIATES
4) Dear CA 'S
This is one of the Serious Harassment by the Police Required to be deeply Protest by CA Fraternity of all India irrespective of States.Further Serious Steps to be taken by CA general elected body so that stern action including suspension from service would be acted against the Police officers .
CA RAMESH K KEJRIWAL
KEJRIWAL & ASSOCIATES
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS
13&14,Apex Market Complex
Kalpana Square,Cuttack Road
BHUBANESWAR -751006,Odisha
TEL/FAX-2310033,M-9437043043
Email :Kejriwalfca@yahoo.com
Web: www.Kejriwalfca.com
5) Praveen kpraveenca@gmail.com
Its really senseless act the police men.
6) Rishu Gupta rishugupta_cj@yahoo.co.in
This is strange and shameful. This should be stopped.
7) Rohit Agnihotri carohitagnihotri@gmail.com
We are with you
8) Dear Nitesh Ji
Current set up of police system in our country has made it gundaraj in the hands of police to harass anybody whosoever they want to or pressurized to. We should unite together and represent as one force to the higher authorities of Mr Pradeep. This police community is afraid of media because of their reach. We should also set up an example so that police think twice before harassing any CA unnecessarily. This way we will be able to survive together in this cruel set up.Please let me know about any help from side.
CA. Akhil Prashar
9) Dear professional colleague
The whole episode is quite unfortunate and we all are professionals and doing the due diligence to the best of our knowledge and belief and on the basis of information produced to us for our verification. The harassment by police is not desirable and Central council members and especially those representing CA MANOJ GARG region should immediately come forward and initiate action. We all are with him.
CA TARUN KANSAL
FCA,BCOM (Hons), LLB, DIRM, DISA
SVP & ASSOCIATES
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS
1209, NEW DELHI HOUSE,
27, BARAKHAMBA ROAD,
CONNAUGHT PLACE,
NEW DELHI-110001
10) This is very serious matter….This matter should be brought immediately in the notice of ICAI president & Noida officials. And they should speak to SP NOida on this immediately.
Nitishji I request you to speak personally with ICAI officials….
We are all with CA Manoj Garg…..
Rohit Gupta
FCA, CS.
09811175141
11) To remain safe from our side, It would be best if we stop certifying documents of any unknown person other than our regular clients. It is really shameful to know that, such harassment happening to reputed professionals like CA's. Hope Noida Centre of ICAI will take up the matter seriously and help Manoj ji.
CA Sagar Bhandari
Nepal
12) Dear All,
We should take action against this type of officials, because this thing can happen with any of us in future, I request all to join hands.
CA Prakhar Gupta, Rishikesh
13) Girish Vakharia vakhariagirish@gmail.com
In India brutality of cops is well known . If a CA feels helpless, what about an illiterate villager's plight. Unless the cops are punished adequately, cop atrocities will not end
14) DEAR ALL,
IT IS REALLY PAIN FULL FOR THE TREATMENT METED OUT TO CA'S ALL AROUND. WHAT WAS HE CERTIFYING. ITS ONLY THE PERSONS IDENTITY AND ADDRESS. DID IT SIGNIFY THAT HE IS CERTIFYING THAT HE WILL NOT CHEAT OR DO ANY UNLAWFUL THING. AND IF HE COMMITS ANY UNLAWFUL THING THAN CA WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SAME.BUT IF THE SAME IS CERTIFIED BY THE LAWYERS THAN NO BODY WILL EVEN COME TO QUESTION THEM. ITS A PITY OF OUR LIFE THAT WE ARE ALWAYS TREATED BEHIND ADVOCATES IN ALL WALKS OF LIFE.
CA. SUNIL KUMAR JAIN
15) HIMANSHU GUPTA <cahimanshuji@gmail.com>
I too support manoj ji. Complaint should be filed against police officer For harassment.
16) We all have to support our brother Mr. Manoj and help him to come out of such a worst situation.
Regards
Rajat jain
17) Hi
It is really pain full to hear that such kind of treatment is meated out to a professional. And the same can happen to any one. I pledge my support for the cause and being a part of CA family I stand behind every CA.
Pankaj Kapoor
18) Nitesh ji,
Felt so bad to read email of Manoj ji.
NIRC, Local Branch, Bar association may meet the higher officials.
Here we mive together to higher authorities in any of such kind of matter.
Kindly guide.
CA Rajeev K Sharma 09814214503
19) We should extend our fullest support to our Professional Peer as this is something having direct bearing with our Profession .I expect Senior Professional Colleagues and Nominated Members of
Ghaziabad Chapter , Jurisdictional Central Council Members should come forward to support our professional bother immediately .We need to show the authorities that We belong to a Nobel
Profession and members of our institute are tied with a threat of Professional Brother Hood .
With Regards
CA. Tarun Agarwal
| 20) Gaurav Singh cagauravindia@gmail.com | |
After reading email of Manoj ji, its painful for us & also it raises a question about creditability of our profession. So I am requested to ALL CA come together to save our Profession.
| 21) Rahul Mittal mittalcarahul@gmail.com | |
Media should be contracted to cover this news...
This is disturbing and I would suggest Mr Garg to talk to Pradeep Kumar's seniors and clarify the matter.
Harassment happen till we allow it to happen. People like Pradeep kumar are few and cannot be the last authority to decide what they think is correct.
23) Ashok Arora caashokarora@gmail.com
We have to file complaint against this police official pradeep kr to harrass a professional ca faculty.
24) deepakjainca@rediffmail.com
we should raise this question through regional council of ICAI
25) My Dear Professional Brothers.
Noida Authority and its Harami Officials. These are harami in reality.
I have written more than 5000 letters to Noida Authority.
CA M K Dubllsh
26) Dear CA Manoj,
I am with you in all respects...n can understand the phase u r going thru...
We should not allow happening such disguasting things to us.I have my cousin advocate practising in supreme court n high court.If you want i can give you his contacts..and i am sure he will resolve the matter...Further he will not charge a penny from you.He is also associated with ICAI and participating in various seminars.You need not to worry...he shall learn the lesson to so called policeman...
Regards
CA. Sourabh Maini
Mb.9781714040
Dear Did you got confirmation on the certificate from him and got it countersigned. Whether you wrote that this is being issued at the request of the party concerned.You should get legal advise and if so file application with Commissioner for harrassment by the Government Officer with the threat to your life. Your collegue in profession.
28) Dear all, From this incident I would like to impress all my fellow colleagues to not issue any certificate to walk in client. Walk in client is welcome for all professional assignments but we should be careful if unknown person asks for only a certificate from us.
Thks
29) We are with you Mr. Manoj Garg.
CA Manoj Rungta
30) We are with you
Rohit Agnihotri carohitagnihotri@gmail.com
31) We all have to support our brother Mr. Manoj and help him to come out of such a worst situation.
Regards
Rajat jain
32) Dear friends,
The behavior of the said officer is really very same full, we should put this matter to the right fouram and deal with this in the interest of our profession n dignity.
Thanks n regards
CA Ashok kumar Agarwal
09333797746
ALL INDIA SUPPORT FOR MANOJ JEE
1) sanjeevjhunjhunwala@gmail.com
I pledge my support n we should stand by the profession
2)
Hi
It is really pain full to hear that such kind of treatment is meated out to a professional. And the same can happen to any one. I pledge my support for the cause and being a part of CA family I stand behind every CA.
Pankaj Kapoor
2) Nitesh ji,
Felt so bad to read email of Manoj ji.
NIRC, Local Branch, Bar association may meet the higher officials.
Here we mive together to higher authorities in any of such kind of matter.
Kindly guide.
CA Rajeev K Sharma 09814214503
3) We should extend our fullest support to our Professional Peer as this is something having direct bearing with our Profession .I expect Senior Professional Colleagues and Nominated Members of
Ghaziabad Chapter , Jurisdictional Central Council Members should come forward to support our professional bother immediately .We need to show the authorities that We belong to a Nobel
Profession and members of our institute are tied with a threat of Professional Brother Hood .
With Regards
CA. Tarun Agarwal
4) Gaurav Singh cagauravindia@gmail.com
To ALL CA
After reading email of Manoj ji, its painful for us & also it raises a question about creditability of our profession. So I am requested to ALL CA come together to save our Profession.
5)Rahul Mittal mittalcarahul@gmail.com
Media should be contracted to cover this news...
This is disturbing and I would suggest Mr Garg to talk to Pradeep Kumar's seniors and clarify the matter.
Harassment happen till we allow it to happen. People like Pradeep kumar are few and cannot be the last authority to decide what they think is correct.
7) Ashok Arora caashokarora@gmail.com
We have to file complaint against this police official pradeep kr to harrass a professional ca faculty.
8) deepakjainca@rediffmail.com
we should raise this question through regional council of ICAI
9) My Dear Professional Brothers.
Noida Authority and its Harami Officials. These are harami in reality. I have written more than 5000 letters to Noida Authority.
CA M K Dubllsh
10) Dear CA Manoj
I am with you in all respects...n can understand the phase u r going thru...We should not allow happening such disgusting things to us.I have my cousin advocate practising in supreme court n high court. If you want i can give you his contacts..and i am sure he will resolve the matter...Further he will not charge a penny from you. He is also associated with ICAI and participating in various seminars.
You need not to worry...he shall learn the lesson to so called policeman...
Regards
CA. Sourabh Maini
Mb.9781714040
Dear Did you got confirmation on the certificate from him and got it countersigned. Whether you wrote that this is being issued at the request of the party concerned.You should get legal advise and if so file application with Commissioner for harrassment by the Government Officer with the threat to your life. Your collegue in profession.
12) Dear all, From this incident I would like to impress all my fellow colleagues to not issue any certificate to walk in client. Walk in client is welcome for all professional assignments but we should be careful if unknown person asks for only a certificate from us.
13) We are with you Mr. Manoj Garg.
CA Manoj Rungta
14) We are with you, Rohit Agnihotri carohitagnihotri@gmail.com
15) We all have to support our brother Mr. Manoj and help him to come out of such a worst situation.
Regards
Rajat jain
16) Dear friends,The behavior of the said officer is really very same full, we should
put this matter to the right fouram and deal with this in the
interest of our profession n dignity.
Thanks n regards
CA Ashok kumar Agarwal
09333797746
1) DEAR ALL,
IT IS REALLY PAIN FULL FOR THE TREATMENT METED OUT TO CA'S ALL AROUND. WHAT WAS HE CERTIFYING. ITS ONLY THE PERSONS IDENTITY AND ADDRESS. DID IT SIGNIFY THAT HE IS CERTIFYING THAT HE WILL NOT CHEAT OR DO ANY UNLAWFUL THING. AND IF HE COMMITS ANY UNLAWFUL THING THAN CA WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SAME.BUT IF THE SAME IS CERTIFIED BY THE LAWYERS THAN NO BODY WILL EVEN COME TO QUESTION THEM. ITS A PITY OF OUR LIFE THAT WE ARE ALWAYS TREATED BEHIND ADVOCATES IN ALL WALKS OF LIFE.
CA. SUNIL KUMAR JAIN
2) Generallly these kind of certificate are issued to banks that the person is known personally. If a person issues a certificate just based on pan card or voting car does not mean tha he may not know him personally. In my opinion such certificate should not be issued unless one knows personally. We should take legal opinion before making it a big issue.
O p agarwal
3) Dear Professional friends
we should save our profession.we should make strong community for From this incident I would like to impress all my fellow colleagues to not issue any certificate to walk in client. Walk in client is welcome for all professional assignments but we should be careful if unknown person asks for only a certificate from us
FCA MANISH GUPTA
MANISH SHIV GUPTA AND ASSOCIATES
4) Dear CA 'S
This is one of the Serious Harassment by the Police Required to be deeply Protest by CA Fraternity of all India irrespective of States.Further Serious Steps to be taken by CA general elected body so that stern action including suspension from service would be acted against the Police officers .
CA RAMESH K KEJRIWAL
KEJRIWAL & ASSOCIATES
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS
13&14,Apex Market Complex
Kalpana Square,Cuttack Road
BHUBANESWAR -751006,Odisha
TEL/FAX-2310033,M-9437043043
Email :Kejriwalfca@yahoo.com
Web: www.Kejriwalfca.com
5) Praveen kpraveenca@gmail.com
Its really senseless act the police men.
6) Rishu Gupta rishugupta_cj@yahoo.co.in
This is strange and shameful. This should be stopped.
7) Rohit Agnihotri carohitagnihotri@gmail.com
We are with you
8) Dear Nitesh Ji
Current set up of police system in our country has made it gundaraj in the hands of police to harass anybody whosoever they want to or pressurized to. We should unite together and represent as one force to the higher authorities of Mr Pradeep. This police community is afraid of media because of their reach. We should also set up an example so that police think twice before harassing any CA unnecessarily. This way we will be able to survive together in this cruel set up.Please let me know about any help from side.
CA. Akhil Prashar
9) Dear professional colleague
The whole episode is quite unfortunate and we all are professionals and doing the due diligence to the best of our knowledge and belief and on the basis of information produced to us for our verification. The harassment by police is not desirable and Central council members and especially those representing CA MANOJ GARG region should immediately come forward and initiate action. We all are with him.
CA TARUN KANSAL
FCA,BCOM (Hons), LLB, DIRM, DISA
SVP & ASSOCIATES
CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS
1209, NEW DELHI HOUSE,
27, BARAKHAMBA ROAD,
CONNAUGHT PLACE,
NEW DELHI-110001
10) This is very serious matter….This matter should be brought immediately in the notice of ICAI president & Noida officials. And they should speak to SP NOida on this immediately.
Nitishji I request you to speak personally with ICAI officials….
We are all with CA Manoj Garg…..
Rohit Gupta
FCA, CS.
09811175141
11) To remain safe from our side, It would be best if we stop certifying documents of any unknown person other than our regular clients. It is really shameful to know that, such harassment happening to reputed professionals like CA's. Hope Noida Centre of ICAI will take up the matter seriously and help Manoj ji.
CA Sagar Bhandari
Nepal
12) Dear All,
We should take action against this type of officials, because this thing can happen with any of us in future, I request all to join hands.
CA Prakhar Gupta, Rishikesh
13) Girish Vakharia vakhariagirish@gmail.com
In India brutality of cops is well known . If a CA feels helpless, what about an illiterate villager's plight. Unless the cops are punished adequately, cop atrocities will not end
14) DEAR ALL,
IT IS REALLY PAIN FULL FOR THE TREATMENT METED OUT TO CA'S ALL AROUND. WHAT WAS HE CERTIFYING. ITS ONLY THE PERSONS IDENTITY AND ADDRESS. DID IT SIGNIFY THAT HE IS CERTIFYING THAT HE WILL NOT CHEAT OR DO ANY UNLAWFUL THING. AND IF HE COMMITS ANY UNLAWFUL THING THAN CA WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SAME.BUT IF THE SAME IS CERTIFIED BY THE LAWYERS THAN NO BODY WILL EVEN COME TO QUESTION THEM. ITS A PITY OF OUR LIFE THAT WE ARE ALWAYS TREATED BEHIND ADVOCATES IN ALL WALKS OF LIFE.
CA. SUNIL KUMAR JAIN
15) HIMANSHU GUPTA <cahimanshuji@gmail.com>
I too support manoj ji. Complaint should be filed against police officer For harassment.
16) We all have to support our brother Mr. Manoj and help him to come out of such a worst situation.
Regards
Rajat jain
17) Hi, It is really pain full to hear that such kind of treatment is meated out to a professional. And the same can happen to any one. I pledge my support for the cause and being a part of CA family I stand behind every CA.
Pankaj Kapoor
18) Nitesh ji,Felt so bad to read email of Manoj ji.
NIRC, Local Branch, Bar association may meet the higher officials.
Here we mive together to higher authorities in any of such kind of matter.
Kindly guide.
CA Rajeev K Sharma 09814214503
19) We should extend our fullest support to our Professional Peer as this is something having direct bearing with our Profession .I expect Senior Professional Colleagues and Nominated Members of Ghaziabad Chapter , Jurisdictional Central Council Members should come forward to support our professional bother immediately .We need to show the authorities that We belong to a NobelProfession and members of our institute are tied with a threat of Professional Brother Hood .
With Regards
CA. Tarun Agarwal
| 20) Gaurav Singh cagauravindia@gmail.com | |
After reading email of Manoj ji, its painful for us & also it raises a question about creditability of our profession. So I am requested to ALL CA come together to save our Profession.
| 21) Rahul Mittal mittalcarahul@gmail.com | |
Media should be contracted to cover this news...
This is disturbing and I would suggest Mr Garg to talk to Pradeep Kumar's seniors and clarify the matter. Harassment happen till we allow it to happen. People like Pradeep kumar are few and cannot be the last authority to decide what they think is correct.
23) Ashok Arora caashokarora@gmail.com
We have to file complaint against this police official pradeep kr to harrass a professional ca faculty.
24) deepakjainca@rediffmail.com
we should raise this question through regional council of ICAI
25) My Dear Professional Brothers.
Noida Authority and its Harami Officials. These are harami in reality.
I have written more than 5000 letters to Noida Authority.
CA M K Dubllsh
26) Dear CA Manoj,
I am with you in all respects...n can understand the phase u r going thru...
We should not allow happening such disguasting things to us.I have my cousin advocate practising in supreme court n high court.If you want i can give you his contacts..and i am sure he will resolve the matter...Further he will not charge a penny from you.He is also associated with ICAI and participating in various seminars.You need not to worry...he shall learn the lesson to so called policeman...
Regards
CA. Sourabh Maini
Mb.9781714040
Dear Did you got confirmation on the certificate from him and got it countersigned. Whether you wrote that this is being issued at the request of the party concerned.You should get legal advise and if so file application with Commissioner for harrassment by the Government Officer with the threat to your life. Your collegue in profession.
28) Dear all, From this incident I would like to impress all my fellow colleagues to not issue any certificate to walk in client. Walk in client is welcome for all professional assignments but we should be careful if unknown person asks for only a certificate from us.Thks
29) We are with you Mr. Manoj Garg.
CA Manoj Rungta
30) We are with you
Rohit Agnihotri carohitagnihotri@gmail.com
31) We all have to support our brother Mr. Manoj and help him to come out of such a worst situation.
Regards
Rajat jain
32) Dear friends,
The behavior of the said officer is really very same full, we should put this matter to the right fouram and deal with this in the interest of our profession n dignity.
Thanks n regards
CA Ashok kumar Agarwal
09333797746
LETTER TO ICAI BY CA NITESH MORE
Dear Sir,
Subject: Harassment By Noida Police to a Chartered Accountant
I am a practicing Chartered Accountant running my own CA firm in Noida since 2005.
Before three months a person namely Mr. Vikrant Bajaj came to my office with his documents and requested for a CA certification for opening bank account with Axis Bank.I issued a certificate to the bank, in which I verified the name and address of the person on the basis of the following documents:-
1) PAN Card (issued by Income Tax Department),
2) ST-2, Service tax registration certificate (issued by Central Board of Excise and Custom); and
3) voter-id card (issued by Election Comission of India).It was clearly mentioned in the certificate that this certificate is issued on the basis of these documents only. It was nowhere mentioned that I take his guarantee or responsibility or I know him.
On 28th March, a police inspector Mr. Pradeep Kumar enquired me about Mr.
documents to issue a certificate to open a Bank Account with Axis Bank. I
But still the police inspector made pressure upon me and force me to make
to me for each and every thing they do and put me in jail and will recoverthe money of fraud from me. This behavior of Mr. Pradreep Kumar is quite
again and harassing me baselessly.This conduct of a police inspector isvery painful.
I don't understand whether Police is to help public or to harass public.
If Police will behave like this and held responsible to professionals only due to certification done by them after taking care of due diligence, then no Chartered Accountant, Company Secretaries, Advocates, Ghazatted Officer will certify any documents of any person. Why government give us an authority to certify the documents of people?
"This is a time to come together and tell everyone that we professionals
--
*Thanks & Regards,*
*CA*
* Manoj Garg(FCA, DISA)*
*__________________*
*Manoj Ratan & AssociatesChartered Accountants*Office :- C-302, First
Floor,
Sec-10, Noida,U.P.-201301
Phone - +91 0120 4219674
Mobile - +91 9899416237
<http://www.manojratanassociates.com/>
1) Hi
It is really pain full to hear that such kind of treatment is meated out to a professional. And the same can happen to any one. I pledge my support for the cause and being a part of CA family I stand behind every CA.
Pankaj Kapoor
Felt so bad to read email of Manoj ji.
NIRC, Local Branch, Bar association may meet the higher officials.
Here we mive together to higher authorities in any of such kind of matter.
Kindly guide.
CA Rajeev K Sharma 09814214503
I expect Senior Professional Colleagues and Nominated Members of
Ghaziabad Chapter , Jurisdictional Central Council Members should
come forward to support our professional bother immediately .
We need to show the authorities that We belong to a Nobel
Profession and members of our institute are tied with a threat of
Professional Brother Hood .
With Regards
CA. Tarun Agarwal
| Gaurav Singh cagauravindia@gmail.com | |
| Rahul Mittal mittalcarahul@gmail.com | |
Harassment happen till we allow it to happen. People like Pradeep kumar are few and cannot be the last authority to decide what they think is correct.
I am with you in all respects...n can understand the phase u r going thru...
We should not allow happening such disguasting things to us.
I have my cousin advocate practising in supreme court n high court.
If you want i can give you his contacts..and i am sure he will resolve the matter...
Further he will not charge a penny from you.
He is also associated with ICAI and participating in various seminars.
You need not to worry...he shall learn the lesson to so called policeman...
Regards
CA. Sourabh Maini
Mb.9781714040
Dear Did you got confirmation on the certificate from him and got it countersigned. Whether you wrote that this is being issued at the request of the party concerned.You should get legal advise and if so file application with Commissioner for harrassment by the Government Officer with the threat to your life. Your collegue in profession.
From this incident I would like to impress all my fellow colleagues to not issue any certificate to walk in client. Walk in client is welcome for all professional assignments but we should be careful if unknown person asks for only a certificate from us.
CA Manoj Rungta
The behavior of the said officer is really very same full, we should
put this matter to the right fouram and deal with this in the
interest of our profession n dignity.
Thanks n regards
CA Ashok kumar Agarwal
09333797746
__._,_.___
No comments:
Post a Comment